Versions Compared

Key

  • This line was added.
  • This line was removed.
  • Formatting was changed.

...

The Menchero arithmetic algorithm extends a single-period attribution analysis to multiple-periods by noting that the returns of the portfolio geometrically compound over T periods for the portfolio single-time period return,  , as follows:

The benchmark multiple-period return,  , is as follows:

For small single-period returns, the relative performance is approximately as follows:

As the single-period returns become larger this breaks down due to the characteristic scaling arising from geometric compounding. The Menchero algorithm compensates for this by introducing the following scaling factor,  , in the previous approximation equation:
  
The Menchero algorithm then deduces the correct scaling law that ensures any residual will be small. It is simply the ratio of the average arithmetic excess return to the average geometric excess return:
Image RemovedImage Added
Next, the Menchero algorithm introduces corrective terms, Image Removed Image Added , that distribute the small residual among the time periods so that the following holds exactly:
Image RemovedImage Added
The Image Removed coefficients Image Added coefficients are the final optimized linking coefficients:
Image RemovedImage Added
Finally, the Menchero algorithm derives optimal values for the small Image Removed values Image Added values:
Image RemovedImage Added
Where Image Removed is Image Added is a dummy index of summation.
The following sections summarize the required calculations.

Calculate Total Period Statistics

  1. Calculate the geometrically compounded portfolio and benchmark returns for the total period and the excess difference:

...

  1. Image Added

...


  1. Image Added

...

  1. Image Added

    Calculate the multi-period scaling factor:

...

  1. Image Added

    Calculate single-period excess returns for each period:

...

  1. Image Added

    Calculate the sum of the single-period excess returns across periods:

...

  1. Image Added
  2. Calculate the sum of the squared single-period excess returns across periods:

...

  1. Image Added

Calculate Single Period Statistics

  1. Calculate the single-period scaling factor adjustments using the above previously calculated components:

...

  1. Image Added
  2. Calculate the single-period scaling factors:

...

  1. Image Added
  2. Calculate the single-period fixed income attribution factors across the segments. Superscript A is introduced simply to note an arithmetic style of attribution is being smoothed:

...

  1. Image Added

...


  1. Image Added
  2. Multiply each single-period attribution factor times the single-period scaling factors:

...

  1. Image Added
  2. Calculate multi-period attribution statistics and add the single-period attribution factors to form the multi-period attribution factors:

    Image Added

...

  1.